Influences on writers don’t have to be writers, do they?
As I went down the rabbit hole of thinking about influences on my life and work, I decided to take a little sideways look at an influence that is clear to me but may need some additional light shed on it to make sense of it.
Of course, I am not just a writer, but a singer and percussionist so music has been a major part of my life (and also shows up in my work more often than not—my most recent play is really a disguised musical).
I thought about the moment when I first fell in love with percussion and realized there was one album growing up that made me conga-mad. But it also meant the world to me lyrically and I can even see traces of its idiosyncrasies in my work as well, if I look hard enough.
The first time I fell in love with the conga drums was listening to Harry Connick, Jr.’s album She from 1994. I found it as an audio tape (once again, in my brother’s collection). He had bought it because it did produce one hit for the radio, “I Only Whispered Your Name,” which was featured on The Mask soundtrack. He didn’t care for the rest of the record. It seems most people didn’t. But I thought, 10 year-old I was, it was a masterpiece.
In the early ‘90s, Harry Connick, Jr. rose quickly as that generation’s vocal jazz front-man (a la the “new Sinatra”). There have been “new Sinatras” since, Michael Bublé is the newest, but Harry was not interested in just a career singing in a suit. He has always been restless, fearless (in his way), and morphing into one thing or another.
He shocked all his new-found fans (who had been turned onto him through the When Harry Met Sally… soundtrack) by switching gears entirely from big band jazz to New Orleans funk for two albums in the mid-90s. Neither were very successful, though the latter went Gold, and in fact many audiences revolted when they showed up to hear a big band show and got a complete 180.
You may think of Harry as just a slick commercial act, but there’s something a little dangerous about him. I see him every time he comes to Birmingham and the show is a complete 180 every time. While he is known for a kind of standard vocal jazz, he has made traditional big-band albums (Come by Me), introspective instrumentals (Other Hours), covers of movie musical songs (the irresistibly fun Songs I Heard) and, while these may not sound different or unusual, it should be said Harry never does anything anyone wants him to do. The album of lusciously orchestrated ‘50s tunes (Only You) was a request from a music executive and Harry begrudgingly complied when he realized the idea wasn’t half-bad. Before that, he had been prickly about being asked to do anything. Otherwise, for his brand, he is eclectic, prolific, and a damned good piano player which people forget.
The last time I saw his show, it was not long after Hurricane Katrina. Near the end of the concert, he began talking about New Orleans and am audience member shouted, "I'm from there!" In a moment I can describe as somewhere between funny and maniacal, Harry lobbed his water bottle in the air and pile drove it to the ground, shouting "That doesn't mean you can interrupt me, ma'am!" The audience was laughing, but I knew there was some real frustration there and he played the rest of the concert with a hurt hand.
The time before that concert, it was the Come By Me tour. One audience member, I guess one who had never been to a jazz concert before, heckled Harry mid-way through the show with "Pick it up, Harry!" He meant the tempo, and Harry introspectively turned it into what they call a "teachable moment" about jazz, which I would ruin if I reproduced here. Back to the point: his musicianship.
He is not just a “piano player" as one track on She attests. The final track, “Booker,” a haunting love note to his piano teacher, the troubled but genius James Booker, features Harry on every single instrument and a lyric that might rip your heart out.
It begins:
“And the warden said
‘He won’t need a cell
He has the key
There’s no harsher sentence.
The man’s doin’ life
In the first degree.’
Some people seek to set blame
Some just accept their part
And now you know why Booker
Died of a broken heart.”
Each successive verse has another visitor meeting with the “prisoner,” Booker. With the last verse, it is a doctor. The lyric kinda gets me right here:
“And the doctor said
‘I can see you’re hurt
Just by lookin’ at you.
Pain we can help
But for hurt
There’s nothin’ we can do.’”
Harry’s choking delivery of the last two lines reveals the depth of his ability to deliver the truth of each song. The way he sings the word “hurt” reveals much about his heroin-addicted mentor who began teaching Harry as a way of commuting a sentence (Harry was NOLA’s Mayor’s son).
This last stanza is delivered also after a rocking bridge where the various tracks of Harry playing each instrument are spliced together. This instrumental ends with Harry shivering his right hand on the high registers of the piano in much the same way Booker ended a song, invoking some kind of rollicking, skeleton-like horror.
She was the result of Harry picking up a notebook of poetry by Ramsay McLean and asking Ramsay if he could set it to music. McLean is a New Orleans musician (I’m guessing?) with scarce information online, even in this day and age. McLean wrote the lyrics to Marc Shaiman’s Academy Award-nominated song “A Wink and a Smile” from Sleepless in Seattle. But She seems more a kind of book of rough-hewn, sardonic verse from a man who’s seen it all and has a unique way of expressing himself, indulging in pure creativity. No one talks about creativity—just the plugging-in-and-playing part of writing—is one of the best things about us (and hopefully keeps us young).
As an example of the lyrical playfulness, the album’s second track, “Between Us” (a slickly produced ballad with a mean wah-wah guitar) has this:
“They’re building a bridge,
Links Manhattan with the Heartland.
It’s called the California Ridge.
The country needs to expand.
Saw them lay the first stone.
It was made of wood.
Either way, between us, it’s good.”
The devil if I know what it means (and it might lead you to concur with music critics that the album was quote “dumb”), but it also may be an exteriorization of the kind of slick character you meet on New Orleans sidewalks—you know, the kind who says, “I can tell you where you got your shoes!” and, while taking your money says, “On your feet!” Years later, this bit would actually show up in a Broadway musical Harry wrote called Thou Shalt Not. (It was my first Broadway show. I can still tell you what every stage picture looked like.)
McLean’s poetry, as you can see, is raw and wacky. One could argue the word “expand” above only works because it rhymes, but it’s such a goofy idea anyway—a kind of manifest destiny via a highway system—that you really don’t much care.
My favorite track is “Trouble,” a simple song played on a piano with conga drums and that’s it. The lyric describes a man who moans, “I used to not need nothin’/Now trouble is all I need.”
It is a song that’s both silly and stark, musically pared down yet exciting and tuneful. It is also, like much of the album, written in a kind of NOLA dialect. The opening of Side B (remember, this was a tape) was “To Love the Language,” which begins:
“I is just what I was,
And am ain’t who I be.
To love the language,
You got to be born
On the banks of the Mississippi.”
If you had as much fun reading that, imagine how much fun Harry has singing it.
I could praise each song, but I won’t. I encourage you to listen to it, as well as Connick’s funk follow-up Star Turtle, a concept album that is less good overall but features Harry’s amazing piano virtuosity on “City Beneath the Sea” and a terrific vocal on “Hear Me in the Harmony”—another tribute to Booker, with the following lyric:
“But it’s really hard to sing
When nobody hears your song.
Just close your eyes.
You can hear me in the harmony.
“I thought I learned from getting burned.
I bought a suit of armor and silver cane.
I found a little man who’d be proud of me,
But he had to get up early
And I had to get back to my pain.”
Immediately, as nice as that last line is, you can see the problem. Apparently there was a bust-up between McLean and Connick and Connick took over the lyric writing himself on Star Turtle, and while some of his lyrics are great, they are not as wild and weirdly introspective and goofy and lovable as those of McLean. The whole thing makes Harry’s funk experiment fizzle out.
To be truthful, I don’t know what funk is, or should be. I don’t even know if She qualifies, but I dig it. It is an awesome album and it has been with me ever since, mostly exposing me to poetry for the first time. Ever since, I have had no desire to write verse which was academic or ethereal, but playful, even if said playfulness could be described by others as dumb.
Keep Playing!
It all started with a “she.” Here is her song. Hope you dig it too.